Mahoney

  • Our Team
    • Column Team
      • Team
      • Kevin J. Mahoney
      • Joan M. LeGraw
      • Georgia Pasqualone
      • Roisin
  • Practice Areas
    • Column One
      • Drug Offenses
      • Crimes of Violence
      • Sex Crimes
      • Motor Vehicle Offenses
      • Theft Crimes
      • Illegal Possession of Firearms
      • Obstructing Justice Offenses
      • White Collar Crimes
      • Federal Defense
      • Probation Violations
      • Restraining Orders
      • Professional Misconduct
      • Custody of Domestic Pets, Dogs & Cats Litigation
    • Column Two
      • Cyber Crimes
      • Hate Crimes
      • Appeals
      • Clerk Magistrate Hearings
      • Immigration
      • Civil Litigation
      • Civil Suits Against Law Enforcement
      • Personal Injury
      • College Crimes
      • Title IX Investigations
      • Juvenile Law
      • Estate Planning & Asset Protection
      • Last Will and Testament
      • Representation Before DCF
      • Dangerous or Nuisance Dog Defense
  • What Should I Do?
    • Cloumn One
      • Selecting a Winning Lawyer
      • Recommended Lawyers
      • Succeeding With Your Lawyer
      • Right to a Telephone Call
      • Miranda Rights
      • Should I Speak with Police?
      • Coping With Stress of Court
      • Bill of Rights
      • Mass Declaration of Rights
      • Street Encounters or Terry Stops
      • Cooperating With DEA or Police
    • Column Two
      • Common Defenses
      • Right to Self-Defense
      • Reasonable Doubt
      • What to Wear to Court
      • How to Behave in Court
      • Overview of the Justice System
      • Massachusetts Criminal Defense Lawyer
      • Cambridge Drug Trafficking Lawyer: Knock and Talk
      • Motor Vehicle Searches
  • Forensics
    • Column One
      • Forensic Experts
      • Preserving the Crime Scene
      • Collecting Evidence
      • Trace Evidence
      • Fingerprint Evidence
      • Autopsy
      • Gunshot Wounds
      • Stab Wounds
      • Drowning
      • Child Homicide
      • Rape Kit
    • Column Two
      • DNA Evidence
      • Forensic Dentistry
      • Forensic Botany
      • Toxicology
  • Mahoney in the Media
    • In the News
    • TV Appearances
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact

DNA Evidence

dna-1

Can a Defense Lawyer Challenge DNA Evidence?

What is DNA? How does it Work?

For a Massachusetts criminal defense lawyer representing a client charged with murder or a sex offense, DNA, or Deoxyribonucleic Acid, may prove to be the most difficult evidence to effectively challenge at trial. Without a fundemental understanding of DNA and its shortcomings as evidence, especially with collecting DNA samples, a criminal defense lawyer may be unable to prevent an innocent man or woman with being unfairly convicted.

Cambridge Criminal Defense Lawyer Explains: DNA Evidence

DNA is perhaps best explained as the building block of a cell. A double-stranded molecule found in all cell nuclei, DNA contains the genetic material that makes us who we are (human, blonde, green-eyed, etc.). Each DNA molecule resembles a spiral ladder, often referred to as the “double helix”. Inside each of these “ladders”, exists four organic bases: adenine, cytosine, thymine, and guamine (A, C, T, and G). These organic bases form pairs to complete the “rungs” of this ladder. Every sequence of these pairs carries genetic code. Each segment of this code that governs characteristics of an organism is called a gene. A complete system of human DNA, or “genome,” contains close to four billion base pairs.

Throughout most of this genome, the sequences of base pairs is nearly identical in every human. This is what makes us human. However, in some parts of the genome, the DNA is “polymorphic,” where different sequences occur in different people. These different or distinctive configurations are called “alleles.”

The number of alleles in a human population depends on the “loci,” or specific locations in the genome. Humans, as beings born of two parents, have two copies of genetic material in each cell (one from the mother and one from the father). Because of this, at each locus examined by DNA tests, a person generally has two alleles. This pair is called a “genotype.” A set of genotypes possessed by a person at two or more loci is a “multi-locus group” or a “DNA profile,” meaning that this genotype occurs at multiple places in the sample.

Because DNA profiles are highly variable in a given population, it is highly unlikely that two people will have the same profile. For example, if there are three alleles, (g, h, i), then there are six possible combinations or genotypes (gg, gh, gi, hh, hi, ii). In a larger sample, of , say 100 alleles, there will be many more possibilities. Therefore, in a larger locus, there are many different pairs and the chances of two unrelated people containing the same pairs are few and far between.

Problems with DNA testing

While studies of DNA are an important part of scientific development, the concept of forensic DNA testing is potentially flawed. According to Black and Lee’s Expert Evidence: A Practitioner’s Guide to Law, Science, and the FJC Manual (1997), “…forensic DNA testing is not an independent area of academic science; it is a technical field in which procedures are designed, shaped and performed specifically to play a role in litigation” (p. 200). Therefore, courts and attorneys must then consider the environment in which DNA evidence is being produced. Those who have created the tests, due to financial concerns and reputations to consider in the field of DNA testing, are also the ones validating it.

Another issue to consider is that of human error. One such concern is found in the improper collection and handling of samples; cross-contamination being the largest concern. It has been found, as in the O. J. Simpson case, that technicians were handling blood samples of the alleged perpetrator, and then handling the evidence they were supposed to be typing. This is apparently a common problem, especially when DNA samples and evidence are tested and contained in the same room.

Another aspect of human error that can affect DNA testing is found in the failure to be objective and/or to use blind testing. According to Black and Lee, images gathered from DNA samples are occasionally unclear or foggy. When this occurs, the technician occasionally makes a judgement call as to the markings, therefore skewing the test results. Problems with not using blind testing, or using methods where the technicians have no knowledge of the ownership of the samples or even of the case, also cause problems. An examiner’s results can also be skewed when the examiner knows the expected outcome of the test (p. 249-250).

Kevin J. Mahoney is a Cambridge criminal defense lawyer and author of Relentless Criminal Cross-Examination.

References

These are just a few examples of problems with DNA testing. For more information, review the following material:

Black, Bert and Patricia Lee (Eds.), Expert Evidence: A Practitioner’s Guide to Law, Science, and The FJC Manual, West Group, St. Paul, MN, 1997.

Gonick, Larry and Michael Wheelis, The Cartoon Guide to Genetics, 1983.

Saks, Michael J. “Prevalence and Impact of Ethical Problems in Forensic Science.” 34 Journal of Forensic Science 772, 1989.

“Reference Guide on Forensic DNA Evidence.” FJC Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence.

PRINT THIS PAGE

TOP

Testimonials

  • NS, a DUI client,about 1 month ago

    Attorney Mahoney,

    I just wanted to say thank you for such a wonderful and excellent job you did for me. You were quite impressive up there and you really did your homework catching her in a few lies from previous testimony. You are the best! Even though I never want to be in this situation again, if I know anyone I will give them your name.

    Thank Amy for me too! She is a great asset to have in your office! Very pleasant and understanding.

    Again thank you and go Celtics!
     

    text

  • about 1 month ago

    Kevin Mahoney recently represented me in a case for destruction of property and disorderly conduct. He was extremely thorough and persistent, and despite a great deal of evidence against me, he managed to get the felony charge dropped without having to go to trial.

    I had never been in legal trouble before and had no idea how to proceed, and without his counsel, I am sure that I would have gotten convicted.

    He listened to my specific needs and always acted in my best interest. His knowledge, attention to detail, and general courtroom presence continued to amaze me throughout the entire process.
     

    text

  • M.K.about 1 month ago

    Dear Attorney Mahoney:

    I wish to express my sincere appreciation for your efforts on my behalf. Your defense was truly outstanding. The court room skills that you demonstrated and legal knowledge were truly incomparable. I’m wishing you the very best in your future endeavors.

    In addition, I ‘m looking forward to viewing the Jello Trial on Court T.V. Let me thank you once again.

     

    text

  • about 1 month ago

    Attorney Mahoney,

    Is very knowledgeable and very professional. He has just represented me in a case lasting a year and a half, and he made sure I got a fair trial with a fair jury. He kept me well informed about what would be happening in the court room and always had a well thought out defense for any route of attack the D.A. would be planning on.

    My trial took 2 and a half days and after the jury deliberated for approximately 23 minutes they came back with a “Not guilty” verdict. I would recommend Attorney Mahoney to anyone I know, but I sure hope I dont need him again. : ) .
     

    text

Call 617.492.0055

Available to Respond to Emergencies
24 Hours a Day

Directions

Kevin J. Mahoney’s New Book Coming Soon

The Title IX Sexual Harassment Handbook

"Attorney Mahoney is currently authoring an authoritative and strategy driven compendium on investigating and defending Title IX sexual assault cases for lawyers, students, and universities. The book will be available through James Publishing within months."

  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • What Should I Do?
  • Forensics
  • Mahoney in the Media
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact
© 2023 Mahoney Criminal Defense Group.
All Rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Disclaimer
footer-logo

For a Free in-office Consultation Call 617-492-0055

  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • What Should I Do?
  • Forensics
  • Mahoney in the Media
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Practice Areas
  • Areas we serve
  • Mahoney In the Media